5 reasons Love Island USA went completely off the rails this year

Love Island USA Season 7 drew widespread criticism from fans and critics alike, with many calling it one of the franchise’s most chaotic and disappointing seasons. Critics pointed to several key issues: controversial casting decisions that saw contestants like Yulissa and Cierra leave amid resurfaced offensive posts before or during the show; rampant online harassment that forced some islanders — including Olandria Carthen — to lock comments on their social media; and islanders breaking typical gameplay norms by prioritizing “exploring” over forming lasting connections. Changes to classic elements like Casa Amor and the removal of fan‑favorite segments like Movie Night also frustrated viewers, while a lack of genuine romantic relationships left many feeling there was “no love on the island.” These factors combined to make the season feel disjointed and emotionally exhausting for the audience.